The short answer
We replace, repair and maintain tank and tankless water heaters for Broken Arrow homeowners, with a flat-rate, upfront price before any work starts.
Recent water heater jobs in Broken Arrow
- 75-gallon gas water heater replacement. We removed and hauled away the old tank and installed the new 75-gallon gas unit with stainless steel fittings, flex connectors and hammer arrestors. Read the job story.
- Tankless maintenance and leak repair. During a yearly tankless service, our plumber found a leak at the condensate line connection and ran a new short line straight to the drain. Read the job story.
Starting prices
- AO Smith tank water heater installed: starts at $2,575 (40 gal), $2,755 (50 gal), $5,259 (75 gal)
- Navien tankless installed: starts at $5,999
- Tank water heater repair: starts at $500
You get the exact price upfront before work begins.
Water heater service in Broken Arrow
We are serving Broken Arrow now, and our Broken Arrow office is opening soon. See water heater installation, water heater repair, Navien error codes or all our Broken Arrow plumbing.
Page last updated November 2026.
Pickup, removal and the new tank connections
The homeowner on our 75-gallon Broken Arrow job had already arranged a warranty replacement. The failed tank was a Rheem, and the replacement AO Smith was waiting at Home Depot. Casey and Jared removed the old tank, took it to the store, collected the warrantied replacement and brought it back for installation. The homeowner did not have to move the heavy tank or arrange a separate pickup.
The installation used new connections rather than simply reusing every fitting. The parts included two stainless steel tees, two close nipples, two threaded water hammer arrestors, a ProPress ball valve, ProPress adapters and two 24-inch stainless steel flex connectors. The new ball valve provided an isolation point for future service. The hammer arrestors address the bang from a fast-closing valve.
The homeowner had arranged this particular warranty swap before our visit. It does not mean every aging heater qualifies for a replacement tank under warranty. Michael's repair process includes testing failed components and contacting support when needed because individual parts may still carry warranty coverage. The actual warranty and diagnosed fault determine what can be supplied under warranty; collecting this homeowner's replacement does not tell us what coverage another heater may have.
The leak was at the condensate connection
Our other Broken Arrow tankless visit combined yearly service with a reported leak. Travis found the condensate line connection used a brass fitting with PEX. He removed that fitting, expanded three-quarter-inch PEX and ran a short, one-foot line directly to the drain. The leak repair addressed that connection; it was not a tankless unit replacement.
The annual service included heat-exchanger descaling with flushing chemicals and checking the fittings and filters. This visit included checking the filters, not replacing them; the account does not list a separate set of measured test results. It shows why a maintenance visit includes inspecting the surrounding connections as well as flushing the heater. A leak near the unit needs its own source identified, even when service is already due.
For a tank heater, Michael explains a similar difference: leaking top flex connectors are often repairable, while a tank split internally needs replacement. The Broken Arrow tank job also advises planning replacement around 10 to 15 years and checking earlier when heavy rust appears at the top connections or within the combustion chamber. A visible connection leak and internal tank failure should not be treated as the same condition.
Straight Answers
How much does a water heater replacement cost in Broken Arrow?
An AO Smith tank water heater installed starts at $2,575 for 40 gallons, $2,755 for 50 gallons and $5,259 for 75 gallons. You get the exact price upfront.
Do you service tankless water heaters in Broken Arrow?
Yes. We do yearly tankless maintenance and repairs in Broken Arrow, and Navien tankless installed starts at $5,999.
Will you haul away my old water heater?
Yes. On our Broken Arrow 75-gallon replacement, we removed and took away the old tank.
Can a Broken Arrow warranty tank swap include collecting the replacement?
Yes. On the documented 75-gallon job, Casey and Jared took the old heater to Home Depot and collected the replacement tank the homeowner had already arranged under warranty.
Was the Broken Arrow tankless leak inside the heat exchanger?
The documented leak was at the condensate line connection, which Travis replaced with a short line to the drain.
Were the old flex connectors reused on the 75-gallon job?
No. The installation included two new 24-inch stainless steel flex connectors.

