On the job in Tulsa




At a glance
- Where: Tulsa, OK 74135
- Completed: November 16, 2026
- Services: Water heater repair · Water heater installation
- Licensed: Oklahoma plumbing license #035596
What the homeowner needed
This Tulsa home in ZIP 74135 has its water heater tucked in a tight closet, which is why the homeowner needed a slim model. A standard 40-gallon tank is too wide for spaces like this; a slim 40-gallon gas tank is taller and narrower and fits where the old one stood.
The homeowner approved our estimate for a new 40-gallon slim gas water heater. Because they approved the work, we refunded the service charge from the first visit. That is how our service call works: it is waived when you approve the repair.
A new tank with a bad burner
The install itself went in, but something was wrong with the new heater. The burner assembly was "puttering," in our tech's word. That is a sputtering, uneven flame instead of a steady blue burn. On a brand-new heater, that is not a venting or gas-pressure problem you fix with an adjustment. Travis and Conner looked it over and concluded the burner assembly had been damaged at the factory.
Rather than send the homeowner off to deal with the manufacturer, they called A.O. Smith directly from the job. A.O. Smith agreed, issued the replacement part and gave us a warranty claim number. The burner replacement then went on our schedule as a return visit, covered under the manufacturer's warranty.
While they were in the house they spotted one more thing. The washing machine supply hoses were leaking at the boiler drains they connect to. That is not part of the water heater job, so we told the homeowner about it and left the decision with them.
Bringing the closet up to code
The estimate covered more than dropping in a tank. A water heater install is the moment to fix everything around it that is out of date, and in this closet that meant several pieces:
- A new drip pan under the heater.
- An upgraded gas line, with a new flexible connector and a new shutoff valve at the heater.
- A new main water shutoff valve.
- An expansion tank on the cold side.
- Water hammer arrestors.
- Haul-away and disposal of the old tank.
If any venting outside the mechanical room had needed replacing, that would have been extra, and we said so in the estimate. The heater itself is an A.O. Smith, the brand we use on tank water heaters.
Why an expansion tank and arrestors
Many homes in this part of Tulsa now have a pressure-reducing valve or a check valve at the meter. That makes the plumbing a "closed" system: when water heats up and expands, it has nowhere to go but back into your pipes. An expansion tank gives that water a place to go, which takes stress off the tank, the relief valve and the fixtures.
Water hammer arrestors deal with the bang you sometimes hear when a washer or dishwasher valve snaps shut. They are small, cheap and worth adding while the walls around the heater are open.
None of that would have helped with the burner, though. A sputtering flame on a new appliance is a parts problem, and the right move was to stop and get the manufacturer involved rather than keep tinkering with a gas appliance.
Where things stood when we left
When the crew left on November 16, the new 40-gallon slim gas heater was installed with its drip pan, upgraded gas connection, new main shutoff, expansion tank and arrestors. The manufacturer had approved the warranty part for the burner assembly, and the homeowner was being scheduled for the swap. The homeowner also knew about the leaking washer hoses so they could deal with them.
That is the honest status. The burner swap was a follow-up visit, not something we finished that night, and we are not going to describe it as done before it was.
Fitting a tank into a tight closet
Many Tulsa homes built in the 1970s and 1980s put the water heater in a hall closet or a small mechanical room sized for the tank that was there on day one. Standard 40-gallon gas tanks have grown wider since then, partly because of added insulation. When the old tank fails, a standard replacement may not fit through the door or may sit too close to the walls for the required clearances.
A slim tank solves that by going taller and narrower while holding the same 40 gallons. The trade-off is height: you have to check that the vent connector and draft hood still line up with the existing flue. That is why the estimate flagged venting outside the mechanical room as a possible extra. If the flue had needed rework, we would have said so before starting.
On this job the closet also got a new main water shutoff. If anything ever goes wrong with the heater, the homeowner can now shut the house off fast without hunting for the meter.
What this means for your home
New appliances can arrive with defects. If a brand-new gas water heater sputters, makes a puttering sound or has a flame that will not settle down, turn it off and call your installer. Do not keep relighting it. A licensed plumber can tell the difference between an installation problem and a part that failed at the factory, and can work the warranty with the manufacturer for you.
If your heater sits in a closet, ask about a slim model before you assume you need to rebuild the closet. See replacing a water heater in Tulsa and no hot water? quick checks.
Services on this job: Water heater repair · Water heater installation · Plumber in Tulsa · How our pricing works · All job stories
Straight Answers
What should I do if my new gas water heater burner is sputtering?
Turn the heater off and call your installer. On this Tulsa job the burner assembly on a new 40-gallon slim gas heater was damaged at the factory, so we called A.O. Smith, got the warranty part and scheduled the replacement.

