The short answer
We unjam, repair and replace garbage disposals in Broken Arrow homes and rentals, with a flat-rate, upfront price before any work starts.
Recent garbage disposal jobs in Broken Arrow
- Leaking disposal after a jam. A coin dropped into the disposal, and forcing it out with a tool cracked the base and caused a leak. We installed a new disposal. Read the job story.
- Rental property repairs. We replaced a failing disposal and fixed a toilet flapper and a faucet cartridge and handle in one visit. Read the job story.
Before you call
Never reach into a disposal, and do not force a jam out with a tool. That is how the leak in our Broken Arrow job started. Turn the power off and call us.
Starting prices
- Garbage disposal unjam: starts at $99
- Install a disposal you already bought: starts at $283
- 1/2 HP disposal installed: starts at $433
- 3/4 HP disposal installed: starts at $780
We are serving Broken Arrow now, and our Broken Arrow office is opening soon. See garbage disposal service or all our Broken Arrow plumbing.
Page last updated November 2026.
Why a jam and a leaking base are different repairs
In the coin-jam visit, Trystan traced the leak to damage from trying to force the object through the unit. The disposal's base was cracked, allowing water to escape beneath the sink. He removed the old disposal, installed a Badger 5, reconnected the kitchen drain and ran water to check the connections. The cracked base meant this disposal needed replacement. Clearing the coin alone would not repair the damaged housing or stop water leaking from it.
The office had explained the service charge before the appointment and told the homeowner the plumber would inspect the unit and price a replacement if necessary. The deciding detail was where the water escaped after the jam, not simply whether the motor made a sound.
Our Broken Arrow coin-jam story includes the actual before-and-after photographs. It also identifies chemical drain cleaners, bones, hard objects, aquarium rocks and metal as things that damage disposals.
The rental visit included an electrical finding
At the rental property we replaced the failing disposal. Our notes from that job also show why we check the electrical supply before blaming the motor: when a reset and unjamming did not bring a disposal back, we tested the connection and found it was not getting power, which is an electrician's repair, not a plumbing one.
On the same visit, a hallway toilet was refilling randomly. Its flapper had deteriorated and broken on one side. We fitted a three-inch replacement and checked operation. A loose tub/shower handle needed a handle and cartridge replacement. At the master vanity, hair and a push-button stopper that did not open fully were contributing to slow drainage.
The toilet, shower and vanity each had a separate problem at the same Broken Arrow property. You can read the findings in the rental repair story. They explain why we inspect the sink connections and the reported symptoms instead of treating every kitchen problem as the same disposal failure.
Choosing a unit for the way you cook
The disposal guidance distinguishes a standard half-horsepower unit from a three-quarter-horsepower option for heavier use. Michael also describes disposals that sit unused for months and become jammed as mineral buildup and rust develop. He recommends operating the unit about every couple of weeks even when you do not regularly put food through it. Water leaking from the bottom is a different warning: he treats a rusted-through unit as a replacement.
Straight Answers
How much does garbage disposal repair cost in Broken Arrow?
Unjamming starts at $99. A new 1/2 HP disposal installed starts at $433, and a 3/4 HP starts at $780.
Can you install a disposal I already bought?
Yes. Installing a customer-supplied disposal starts at $283.
Should I use a tool to clear a jammed disposal?
No. On one Broken Arrow job, forcing a coin out with a tool damaged the base and caused a leak. Turn the power off and call us.
Does a silent disposal always mean its motor has failed?
No. On a Broken Arrow rental job, a disposal that would not run turned out to have no power at the connection, so we pointed the owner to an electrician before anyone paid for a new unit.
Which disposal size do you suggest for heavy kitchen use?
We suggest a three-quarter-horsepower disposal for heavier kitchen use. A half-horsepower unit is the standard option described in our disposal guidance.
What was tested after the coin-damaged unit was replaced?
Trystan reconnected the drain and checked the new disposal installation for leaks.

